The Fundraising Effectiveness Project (FEP), run by the AFP Foundation for Philanthropy and GivingTuesday, publishes quarterly data on US giving. In its year-end report for 2025, overall donor retention edged up from 43.1% to 43.3%. At the same time, the number of donors fell an estimated 3.6% while dollars rose an estimated 5.0%. More money is coming from fewer people, so every donor you lose is harder to replace.
Donor retention is the share of last year’s donors who give again this year. To calculate it, divide the number of returning donors by last year’s total donors and multiply by 100. Small nonprofits raise it mostly with fast, personal thank-yous and regular updates that ask for nothing.
Keeping a donor you already have takes less effort than finding a new one, and the national data shows why that matters right now. Below you will find the formula with a worked example, benchmarks from a source you can open yourself, and a month-by-month thank-you plan that a two-person team can actually run.
Why donor retention matters more than ever
FEP’s report for the second quarter of 2026 adds a detail that matters for small teams: donors who gave seven or more times in 2025 were retained at 90%, compared with 14.4% of one-time donors. Those are year-to-date figures through June under FEP’s new methodology, so they are not directly comparable with the full-year 43.3%. The direction is still clear. Donors who give again and again keep giving, and most losses happen after the first gift.
How to calculate your donor retention rate
The formula is simple: donor retention rate = (donors who gave last year and gave again this year ÷ all donors who gave last year) × 100. The hard part is clean data. Follow these steps once a year, or once a quarter if you want an early warning.
- Export every gift from the last two calendar or fiscal years, with donor ID, date and amount.
- Merge duplicates: the same person with two email addresses, or a couple who give from a joint account, should count once.
- Count the unique donors in the first year.
- Count how many of those donors gave at least once in the second year. New donors from the second year do not count here.
- Divide the second number by the first and multiply by 100.
A worked example
Imagine a food pantry with 180 donors in 2025. In 2026, 72 of them give again. The retention rate is 72 ÷ 180 × 100 = 40%, and the attrition rate (donors lost) is the other 60%. Splitting the same group by donor type shows where the problem is:
| Group | Donors in 2025 | Gave again in 2026 | Retention rate |
|---|---|---|---|
| First-time donors (first gift in 2025) | 100 | 22 | 22% |
| Repeat donors (gave before 2025) | 80 | 50 | 62.5% |
| All donors | 180 | 72 | 40% |
The overall 40% hides two very different stories. Repeat donors are fairly loyal, while almost four in five first-time donors never came back. That points the effort at the second gift, not at a new acquisition campaign.
Dollar retention and small numbers
Some teams also track dollar retention: what last year’s donors gave this year, divided by what the same donors gave last year. If your 180 donors gave $30,000 in 2025 and the returning donors gave $15,000 in 2026, dollar retention is 50%. Definitions vary between software tools, so write down which one you use and keep it the same every year.
With a small base, one person moves the number a lot. If you had 60 donors last year, each of them is worth about 1.7 percentage points. Read the trend over two or three years before you change strategy.
What to compare your rate against
Your first benchmark is your own rate from last year, calculated the same way. The FEP full-year figure of 43.3% for 2025 is a useful sector reference, but compare like with like: a full-year rate against a full-year rate, not against a year-to-date or quarterly figure. Be careful with “average retention” numbers that come without a named source and year; many of them are years old or measured on a different basis.
A thank-you plan across the year
Candid’s team recommends thanking supporters and sharing impact before the year-end appeal, plus a no-ask appreciation event and a January thank-a-thon. Here is that idea turned into a calendar a small team can keep:
| When | What | Who |
|---|---|---|
| Within two days of every gift | Personal thank-you email or letter with the receipt | Staff or a volunteer |
| Within a week, first-time donors | Short phone call or handwritten card | Board member |
| About 30 days after a first gift | Welcome update: what the gift made possible, no ask | Staff |
| Every quarter | One impact update: a story, a number and a photo | Staff |
| Spring or summer | Appreciation event, site visit or virtual tour with no ask | Director and board |
| Gift anniversary | Two-line note that the donor has been with you a year | Volunteer |
| Before GivingTuesday and the year-end appeal | Thank-you and results first, the request a week or two later | Staff |
| January | Thank-a-thon calls to December donors and a year-end giving summary | Board and volunteers |
For bigger gifts, add a personal touch from your director; our guide on how to say thank you for a major gift has seven ideas.
Build one legal detail into the receipt step. According to the IRS, a donor needs a written acknowledgment for any single contribution of $250 or more to claim a deduction, and the page lists what it must include, such as the amount and whether you gave anything in return. This is general information; check your organization’s situation with a tax professional.
Make the second gift your main goal
Since most donors leave after their first gift, the second gift is where a small nonprofit wins or loses. These steps help first-time donors turn into regular ones:
- Show the result before the next ask. A donor who sees what the first gift did has a reason to give again.
- Offer monthly giving early. A small recurring gift removes the need to decide again every time.
- Ask how they want to hear from you. Email, mail or text, and how often. Then respect it.
- Give them something to do besides give. A volunteer shift, a survey or an event invitation builds a relationship that is not only about money.
- Write like a person. A short, specific email from a named sender feels more personal than a newsletter full of logos; our charity email guide covers what to include.
Track retention without expensive software
A spreadsheet is enough for a few hundred donors. Keep one row per donor with columns for first gift date, last gift date, gift count, total given, donor type (first-time or repeat) and the date of the last thank-you. Sort by last gift date every quarter and call or write to anyone who gave a year ago but not since. When the list outgrows a spreadsheet, a donor database or CRM can calculate retention for you; one option is described in our overview of Salesforce for nonprofits.
Start with one number and one calendar
Calculate your retention rate for last year, split it into first-time and repeat donors, and put the thank-you calendar above into your shared calendar before the year-end rush. Check the number again next quarter. If the share of first-time donors who give a second time goes up, the rest of your fundraising gets easier.